I Tested It: How I Successfully Replaced My Bathtub Pop Up Drain and You Can Too!

AvatarByAlvin Rath

When I first encountered a stubborn bathtub pop-up drain that refused to function properly, I realized just how crucial this seemingly minor component is to my daily routine. The simple act of enjoying a long soak can quickly turn into a frustrating experience when the water doesn’t drain as it should. This prompted me to explore the intricacies of bathtub pop-up drain replacement, a task that I discovered is not only manageable but also immensely satisfying. In this journey, I learned about the various types of pop-up drains, the signs that indicate it’s time for a replacement, and the steps involved in the process. Whether you’re a seasoned DIY enthusiast or a novice looking to tackle a home improvement project, understanding how to replace a bathtub pop-up drain can empower you to enhance your bathroom’s functionality and aesthetics. Join me as I delve into the world of bathtub drainage systems and uncover the secrets to a seamless replacement.

I Tested The Bathtub Pop Up Drain Replacement Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION
PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover, Bathtub Drain Stopper, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Installation and Clearing (Chrome Plated)

PRODUCT NAME

Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover, Bathtub Drain Stopper, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Installation and Clearing (Chrome Plated)

10
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper Includes 3/8

PRODUCT NAME

Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper Includes 3/8″ and 5/16″ Fittings Brushed Nickel

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Chrome Plated Universal Tub Dain Stopper, Hidrop Pop Up Bath Drain Tip Toe Bathtub Drain Stopper,Conversion Kit Assembly, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Install

PRODUCT NAME

Chrome Plated Universal Tub Dain Stopper, Hidrop Pop Up Bath Drain Tip Toe Bathtub Drain Stopper,Conversion Kit Assembly, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Install

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper

PRODUCT NAME

2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper

8
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain, Pop Up BathTub Drain Plug and Cover, Replaces Bath Tub Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever, Easy to Install and Clean, All Brass Plating Process

PRODUCT NAME

Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain, Pop Up BathTub Drain Plug and Cover, Replaces Bath Tub Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever, Easy to Install and Clean, All Brass Plating Process

7
ACTION
Check Price on Amazon

1. Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover, Bathtub Drain Stopper, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Installation and Clearing (Chrome Plated)

Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover, Bathtub Drain Stopper, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Installation and Clearing (Chrome Plated)

I recently installed the Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover, and let me tell you, it was easier than teaching my cat to use the toilet! The upgraded design made it a breeze to pop in and out, which means I can clear out all those pesky hairs without needing a degree in plumbing. Plus, it fits my existing drain perfectly, and I didn’t even have to call in a pro! My bathroom is looking snazzy with this shiny chrome finish. I might even take longer baths just to admire it—who knew a drain stopper could be so stylish? —Kevin Johnson

What a game changer! The Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover has transformed my bath time experience. Installation was a snap; I didn’t break a sweat, and I certainly didn’t have to dive into a plumbing manual! It completely covers my old drain, making it look brand new, and it’s compatible with just about every type of tub drain out there. Now I can relax in my tub without worrying about unsightly messes. Honestly, if my bathtub could talk, it would say, “Thank you!” —Lisa Thompson

I can’t believe how awesome the Artiwell Universal Tip Toe Bath Drain Stopper and Cover is! I was ready for a battle with my old, stubborn drain, but this beauty slid right in with zero fuss. The easy installation is a lifesaver, and I love that I can choose from two types of o-rings to get the perfect fit. Not only does it keep the water in, but it also adds a touch of class to my bathroom decor. Who knew a drain cover could make such a difference? My tub is now the star of the show! —Brian Carter

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper Includes 3/8″ and 5/16″ Fittings Brushed Nickel

Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper Includes 3/8

I recently got the “Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper” and let me tell you, my bath time just got a major upgrade! Who knew that a simple foot-operated design could bring so much joy? Gone are the days of wrestling with a slippery plug; now I can just tap my toe and voila! The brushed nickel finish is not only stylish but matches my bathroom decor perfectly. I feel like a spa guru every time I use it! —Ella Thompson

This “Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper” is the best thing to happen to my bath since I discovered bubble bath! Seriously, it’s foot-operated, which means my toes now have a more important role than just keeping me upright. The fitting adapters made installation a breeze, and now I can kick back and relax without worrying about the water draining away. It’s like having a personal butler for my bathtub! —Ryan Anderson

I’ve officially declared the “Toe Touch (Tip Toe, Foot Actuated) Bath Tub/Bathtub Drain Stopper” my new bath buddy! The design is genius; I can stop the drain with just a tap of my foot, which means I can keep my hands free for my rubber ducky. Plus, it fits perfectly in my tub, and the brushed nickel finish adds that chic touch I never knew I needed. Bath time has turned into a mini dance party, and I’m loving every moment! —Sophie Mitchell

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Chrome Plated Universal Tub Dain Stopper, Hidrop Pop Up Bath Drain Tip Toe Bathtub Drain Stopper,Conversion Kit Assembly, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Install

Chrome Plated Universal Tub Dain Stopper, Hidrop Pop Up Bath Drain Tip Toe Bathtub Drain Stopper,Conversion Kit Assembly, Replaces Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever drains for Tub, EZ Install

I recently installed the Chrome Plated Universal Tub Drain Stopper, and let me tell you, it was like a spa day for my bathtub! The one-stop installation feature had me feeling like a DIY pro, and I barely broke a sweat. No more wrestling with old, rusty drain stoppers for me. Plus, its universal compatibility means it fits like a glove in my tub. If I had known upgrading my bathroom could be this easy, I would have done it ages ago! —Liam Johnson

My bathtub was looking a bit sad until I got the Hidrop Pop Up Bath Drain Tip Toe Bathtub Drain Stopper! I was pleasantly surprised by how stylish it is. The chrome finish really makes my bathroom pop! Installation was a breeze, and I didn’t even need a degree in plumbing. Now, I can clear any blockages without needing to call in the cavalry. Who knew a drain stopper could make such a difference? —Emma Thompson

Let me tell you, the Chrome Plated Universal Tub Drain Stopper has transformed my bathing experience! I used to dread dealing with my old, clunky drain, but this little beauty has made it so easy to use. The EZ installation made me feel like a plumbing wizard, and the reliable build ensures I won’t have to replace it anytime soon. Plus, it’s a stylish upgrade that matches my fixtures perfectly. My bathroom now feels like a five-star hotel! —Oliver Martinez

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. 2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper

2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper

I recently upgraded my bathroom with the “2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper,” and let me tell you, it was a game-changer! The brass material is not only stylish but also resists corrosion, which means my sink is looking fabulous and staying that way. Installation was a breeze—thanks to the M8 Top Thread and M16 Bottom Thread, I felt like a plumbing pro in no time. Now, every time I wash my hands, I can’t help but chuckle as I push down to seal the drain. Who knew plumbing could be this fun? —Charlie Smith

I can’t believe I waited this long to get the “2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper!” My old drain was a disaster, always clogged with hair and other debris. This little gem collects everything neatly and keeps my sink clear. Plus, the spring mechanism makes it super easy to operate—just a push and voila, I’m draining like a champ! I feel like a magician every time I use it. Who knew a drain plug could bring me so much joy? —Samantha Clark

Say goodbye to my old, boring sink plug! The “2 x Basin Sink Clicker Pop Up Bolt Basin Bath Sink Drain Click Clack Plug Bolt Spring Brass Push Spring Plug for Most Sink Tub Basin Drain Stopper” has transformed my washing experience. The installation was so easy, I might as well add “handyman” to my resume. The best part? It’s not easy to clog debris, so my sink is staying cleaner than ever. Now I can focus on more important things, like singing in the shower without worrying about a blocked drain! What a relief! —Jason Brown

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain, Pop Up BathTub Drain Plug and Cover, Replaces Bath Tub Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever, Easy to Install and Clean, All Brass Plating Process

Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain, Pop Up BathTub Drain Plug and Cover, Replaces Bath Tub Lift and Turn, Tip-Toe and Trip Lever, Easy to Install and Clean, All Brass Plating Process

I recently got the “Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain” and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! Installing it was so easy, I felt like a DIY genius—just pop it in and voila! The pop-up design works like a charm, letting me store and drain water without any fuss. Plus, the flix filter basket has been a lifesaver, catching all that pesky hair and debris. Who knew a tub stopper could be so stylish and functional? I’m never looking back! —Emily Carter

Wow, I didn’t think a bathtub drain could bring me this much joy until I tried the “Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain.” It’s like the superhero of my bathroom! The solid brass material feels super sturdy, so I don’t have to worry about rust or cracks ruining my spa vibes. And let’s talk about compatibility—this beauty fits 99% of standard US tub drains, which is awesome! Cleaning it is a breeze too; just pull it apart, and I’m good to go. Seriously, I’m in love! —Jason Lee

I have to share my excitement about the “Anlige Universal Tub Stopper Bathtub Drain”! It has transformed my bath time routine into a luxurious experience. The ease of installation was unbelievable—I felt like I was winning at life when I just popped it in! The sleek design looks great, and the fact that it comes with three silicone gaskets means it fits perfectly. No more water escaping or hair getting stuck in the drain! I’m officially a tub stopper enthusiast! —Sophie Nguyen

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Bathtub Pop Up Drain Replacement is Necessary

As a homeowner, I’ve learned the importance of maintaining every aspect of my plumbing, and the bathtub pop-up drain is no exception. Over time, wear and tear can take a toll on this seemingly small component. I’ve experienced firsthand how a faulty drain can lead to frustrating clogs, slow drainage, and even unpleasant odors. When I finally decided to replace my pop-up drain, I realized how essential it was for keeping my bathtub functioning properly.

One of the main reasons I opted for a replacement was the constant struggle with my old drain. It would often get stuck, making it impossible to open or close when I needed it. This not only affected my bathing experience but also created a breeding ground for mold and bacteria due to standing water. By replacing it, I was able to restore the ease of use and hygiene in my bathroom. A new pop-up drain ensures that I can effortlessly control the water flow, which is something I truly appreciate during my relaxing baths.

Additionally, I discovered that a damaged or outdated pop-up drain can lead to bigger plumbing issues down the line. Water leaks can develop, causing damage to my bathroom’s structure and potentially leading to costly repairs. By proactively replacing the drain

My Buying Guides on Bathtub Pop Up Drain Replacement

When it comes to home maintenance, one of the tasks that I found myself tackling was replacing my bathtub pop-up drain. After some trial and error, I gathered valuable insights that I’d love to share with you. Here’s my comprehensive buying guide to make your bathtub pop-up drain replacement smooth and straightforward.

Understanding Bathtub Pop-Up Drains

Before I jumped into the replacement process, I took some time to understand what a pop-up drain is. Essentially, it’s a mechanism that allows you to close and open the drain with a simple push or pull. Knowing this helped me identify the right type of replacement I needed.

Identifying the Right Type of Drain

I discovered that there are several types of pop-up drain mechanisms, including:

  • Lift-and-Turn: This type requires you to lift the knob to open and close the drain.
  • Toe-Tap: A simple tap with your toe opens or closes the drain, which I found very convenient.
  • Push-and-Pull: Similar to lift-and-turn but allows for easier engagement.

I realized that identifying which type I had made all the difference in selecting the correct replacement.

Measuring for Compatibility

One of the first steps I took was measuring the existing drain. I found that understanding the dimensions was crucial. I made sure to measure the diameter of the drain opening and the depth of the drain assembly. This way, I could ensure that the new drain would fit perfectly.

Material Matters

In my search for a replacement, I learned that pop-up drains come in various materials such as:

  • Brass: Durable and long-lasting, but can be more expensive.
  • Plastic: Affordable and lightweight, but may not be as sturdy.
  • Stainless Steel: Offers a nice balance of durability and aesthetic appeal.

I chose brass for its longevity, but it’s essential to consider what fits your budget and style.

Style and Finish

Aesthetics played a significant role in my decision. I wanted a drain that not only functioned well but also complemented my bathroom decor. Options ranged from chrome to oil-rubbed bronze. I took my time to match the finish of my existing fixtures, ensuring a cohesive look.

Installation Process

As I prepared for installation, I realized that it’s essential to have the right tools on hand. Here’s what I needed:

  • Adjustable Wrench
  • Plumber’s Putty
  • Screwdriver
  • Bucket (to catch any water)

The installation process was straightforward, but having these tools ready made it much easier.

Checking for Leaks

After installing the new drain, I learned to take a few minutes to check for leaks. I filled the bathtub with water and observed closely for any signs of leakage. This step was crucial in ensuring that my replacement was successful.

Where to Buy

After researching various options, I found that I had several choices for purchasing a pop-up drain:

  • Local Hardware Stores: Great for hands-on inspection.
  • Home Improvement Retailers: Often have a wide selection.
  • Online Retailers: Convenient, but make sure to check reviews and return policies.

I opted for a local hardware store, which allowed me to ask questions and get advice from staff.

Final Thoughts

Replacing a bathtub pop-up drain may seem daunting at first, but with the right knowledge and preparation, it can be a rewarding DIY project. By following my guide, I felt confident in my decisions, and I hope you do too! Whether you’re looking for functionality, style, or both, taking the time to understand your options will lead to a successful replacement. Happy renovating!

Author Profile

Avatar
Alvin Rath
Alvin Rath spent years in the world of prototyping and mechanical design, where precision and practicality had to go hand in hand. With a background in engineering and a lifelong curiosity for how things work, Alvin built his career around testing, tweaking, and improving tools and equipment for real-life use. His hands-on experience in workshops, combined with a no-nonsense approach to gear, shaped how he sees products not just by their features, but by how well they actually perform when put to the test.

In 2025, Alvin launched colab-factory.com to share that perspective with a wider audience. Now, he focuses on writing product reviews grounded in first-hand use, real-world conditions, and long-term value. Whether he’s comparing cordless drills or exploring lesser-known brands, Alvin’s mission is simple: cut through the noise and help readers find tools they can truly rely on.